General General forums for the GTR community.

Will the GTR go the way of the NSX, RX8, others?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 03-09-2008, 05:44 PM
  #21  
GTR Member
 
shahulx's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 59
yea... I'm lucky I guess , I have a place near me called Atlantic Motorsports... And they are good guys... I was their 1st ever customer in my evo 8, but they were big nissan guys, I saw their r33 at the DC auto show
shahulx is offline  
Old 03-09-2008, 07:26 PM
  #22  
GTR Senior Member
 
rmatt8748's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 517
yah, at the same time, it seems that people know the good tuners for the various different tuner cars..

and people will drive/ take their car long distances to get them tuned/serviced at these places

my only fear is that as more and more gets electronic that it will get increasingly hard to tune and modify these cars, still, that's always the problem with new technology and it takes a little time to catch up with itself, it will be expensive at first, but it gets better
rmatt8748 is offline  
Old 03-09-2008, 09:08 PM
  #23  
GTR Member
 
shahulx's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 59
itll be okay... I think the ecu will get cracked sooner or later... Its fine I can do the exhaust and suspension in the meantime
shahulx is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 01:55 AM
  #24  
GTR Senior Member
 
bonzelite's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 869
brilliant view point on the possbile fate of GT-R in the USDM

agree with him or not, he raises some VERY astute points!

from:
http://www.speedsportlife.com/2008/0...e-mighty-gt-r/

Story by Jack Baruth, photo by “bubba sideways”
I can’t count the number of times during my long and painful BMX career when I sat on my bike, sized up some dirt jump, wooden ramp, or fifteen-stair drop-off, and thought long and hard about how much I’d regret what I was about to do, should it go wrong. Most of the time, my pessimism was unfounded - I’d clear the jump, bound over the obstacle, land the drop. Every once in a while, however, I’d lose my balance, slip a pedal, or just plain run out of talent, and for a tiny, sickening fraction of a second, my breath would catch in my throat before I hit the ground to the accompanying “crack” of a broken bone. I never actually heard a bone break, mind you; it always felt like a really sharp pinch in a place where no pinching should be possible. The memory of that little “pinch” is what made me sit on my bike for an extra moment or two before cranking off towards disaster. There were times I’d have liked to just sit there until it was time to go home, but the difference between the rider and the poser is that the poser never stops just sitting there on the bike. You’ll never get hurt just sitting there.
If I don’t make the prediction I’m about to unleash - if I turn this column towards a safer topic, like E85 pricing or trail-braking techniques for FWD race cars - I won’t get hurt. There won’t be any hate mail. Zerin, my long-suffering editor, won’t get any calls from the manufacturers. It’ll be business as usual. I should really shut up right now.
Oh, the hell with that. Let’s pedal towards the jump and make a prediction. I believe that Nissan is making a potentially serious error in importing the new GT-R to the United States and Canada. I believe that they will eventually regret doing so, and that the GT-R will join that time-honored long list of big-money automotive marketing mistakes that contains everything from the Edsel to the Lincoln Blackwood. Yeah, yeah, I know. Some of my dear readers are already searching for the “Respond” button at the bottom of this column so they can make unpleasant and biologically improbable suggestions regarding my momma, while the more action-oriented among you are already GoogleMapping a very special trip for the purpose of beating my face in at the NASA season opener. (It’s April 12, at Mid-Ohio, if you must know.) If there’s anybody left who simply wants to know the reasons behind this particular piece of prophecy… you’ll just have to put the chainsaw down and keep reading.

Before we talk about failure, we have to define what we mean by success. From Nissan’s perspective, I think it’s fair to say that the GT-R will “succeed” if it accomplishes the following pair of tasks:
  • The GT-R must create a “halo effect” that leads to increased showroom traffic, greater sales of less-expensive models, particularly performance models, and a greater and more positive awareness of Nissan and its products among the general public and the enthusiast market.
  • The GT-R must break even in the North American market. Failing that, it shouldn’t lose too much money for Nissan’s North American operations.
Note that nowhere in there did we talk about selling a zillion GT-Rs, or dominating trackdays across the land, or cutting into Corvette and Porsche sales. We didn’t talk about that stuff because nobody with any sense thinks any of it’s actually going to happen. You see, there’s no real long-term market for the GT-R in North America. To understand why, you have to look at the truly successful entries in the $50,000 - $100,000 performance car market. There are really only two, and we’ve already named them. Both Porsche and the Corvette brand have hundreds of thousands of devoted fans, many of whom can actually afford their products. There are millions of men and women in the United States and Canada who grew up with 911 Turbo or C4 Corvette posters on their wall, and they’re now at an age where they can purchase the cars and enjoy them. There is a strong secondary market for used Porsches and Corvettes, encompassing everything from lightly used Carrera GTs to salvage-title ‘84 Cross-Fire-Injection C4s. Not only is there an entire club for people who want to race Porsches on weekends - the Porsche Club of America - there’s an entire second club for people who think the people in the first club are insufferable ******, and they call it the Porsche Owners’ Club. Meanwhile, there are so many people spending their lives restoring Corvettes that they have multiple sources to certify them - NCRS and Bloomington Gold. In my little hometown of Powell, Ohio, which barely has ten thousand residents, there are at least thirty dues-paying members of PCA, including myself, and there are dozens of Corvettes prowling the streets in the summers. The sheer magnitude of Corvette and Porsche devotion out there is almost unimaginable, and as a result, the two brands combine to sell more than sixty thousand new sports cars in the United States every year.
What’s the Nissan GT-R’s market base? Well, it’s primarily made up of people who play Gran Turismo and its descendants, plus a smattering of kids who thought the car with the Impala-esque taillights in 2Fast 2Furious was pretty cool. Most of these people live in the basements of their parents’ homes. Do you see the problem with the idea of marketing a $70,000 car to people who still live with their parents and who spend all night on XBOX Live? If you don’t, allow me to point it out for you: These kids don’t have any money. They may be tremendously knowledgeable car enthusiasts and very nice people, but when I was seventeen years old, I was a knowledgeable car enthusiast too, and I don’t remember buying any $70,000 cars with my minimum-wage earnings from working the parts counter at David Hobbs BMW.
“Oh, Jack, you’re being deliberately ignorant.” I can hear you now. “There are plenty of wealthy, adult car enthusiasts who know and respect the GT-R.” Well, that’s true. There are plenty of Google employees, “Gold Collar” kids who, although they live with their parents at the age of 27, are earning a GT-R payment by working at Abercrombie & Fitch, and bored rich people who will buy anything that’s new and hot. Hey, there were a few people who laid out a hundred grand for imported Motorex R34 Skylines, right? All of those people might buy a GT-R. The only problem is that very few of these people spent their youths dreaming of the GT-R, and if they did, they were dreaming of the icy-cool, JDM-to-the-max R33 or R34, not this porky monster G35x that Nissan is preparing to bring to these shores. A lot of these people are going to get their seventy grand together and be struck by the undeniable fact that they could buy a Z06 Corvette or Carrera 3.6 with that money! For kids who dreamed of hammering a Nine Eleven down the autobahn, the prospect of slumming down to the Nissan dealer and buying a Nissan from the Nissan dealer who sells Nissans (have I repeated “Nissan” enough here? I hope it’s enough to make the point) is just not gonna happen.
You know what, though? It doesn’t matter. It really doesn’t. Nissan can sell 1,500 GT-Rs a year to Silicon Valley geeks and rich kids who want to indulge their Brian Earl Spilner fantasies, no problem. The Acura NSX sold pretty well at first, too, mostly due to the novelty factor and the fact that people were tired of having their Ferrari 348s towed out of their garages twice a month. All this talk about doing five thousand units a year is sheer bravado, meant to convince the dealers to spend upwards of $300K each to upgrade their shops for “GT-R capability”. This will be a low-volume car, poking along at the bottom of the sales sheet with its distant cousin, the Infiniti Q45, until the cost of a new-generation EPA certification causes Nissan to knock it off the price list. It isn’t the prospect of slow sales that makes me pessimistic about the GT-R. Rather, the real problem, from Nissan’s perspective, is what it will do to their brand, their fans, and their existing cars.
Let’s be honest: the greatest thing about the R34 Nissan Skyline GT-R was that we couldn’t buy it here. In countries where you could buy Nissan’s super-sedan with little difficulty, such as the UK, customers were staggeringly indifferent to “Godzilla”, preferring instead to have a nice Porsche, or maybe a hairy-chested TVR. The only place where the Skyline sold well was Japan, for the same reason the Mustang GT sells well over here: the price/performance ratio was right and it was a domestic-market hero for angry young kids with time on their hands and a few yen in their pockets. Still, Nissan made some hay over here with the legend, which greatly surpassed the reality. Go ahead, tell me that when the “Spec V” Sentra SE-R came out, you didn’t think it was cooler for having that badge on the back. I sure as hell did, and I know I wasn’t alone. Plus, those Cheetos-munching PlayStation addicts of whom we spoke earlier might not have a GT-R’s worth of scratch, but they do have parents who are willing to buy ‘em Sentras with the “sport package”. The actual merits of the Skyline were utterly irrelevant - not when the closest you can get to one is clicking “Buy This Car” in GT4. As the old quote goes, “When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.”
Will that legend, of improbably fast ‘Ring times, thousand-horsepower “Big Birds”, and parking-garage races in Tokyo, still sell Sentras and Altimas when the real GT-R is sitting right next to them on the showroom floor? The answer is a resounding No. It’s one thing to be a Sentra-driving GT-R fan when the real GT-R is safely on the other side of a whole ocean, but what happens when that same kid drives his Sentra to the local community college and sees that his rich-kid classmate has an R35 GT-R? We haven’t even considered what the effect will be on Nissan’s current performance flagship, the fierce and fantastic 350Z. The minute the first GT-R hits these shores, the 350Z becomes the “Nissan with panties”, tucked sadly in the shadow of its mighty stablemate. And with a forty-thousand-dollar price gap between the two, it’s hard to imagine too many 350Z owners trading up to the Car Formerly Known As Skyline. The “halo effect” of the GT-R is going to be very dim in your local Nissan showroom.
I can’t help but think that Nissan had a better option than bringing us a 3800-pound Angry Catfish with a Porsche-sized Monroney slapped on the window; namely, a 500Z. We all know the FM platform will accept the soul-stirring Infiniti quad-cam V8 - it’s already resident in the FX45 and M45 - and there’s no reason a little light tuning wouldn’t result in four hundred horsepower, easy. Add the Track Package Brembos, seam-weld the chassis in the fashion of the Nismo Z, and charge $45K for it. Maybe they could widen the tires a bit for those of us who find the stock Z just a little too reluctant to turn in sometimes. Sure, it might not beat the 997 Turbo around the ‘Ring, but it would hang with an LS3 ‘Vette on Saturday night, and that’s a lot more important on Main Street USA, where the buyers are.
Of course, I could be wrong about all of this. It could all turn out in storybook fashion. The dealers won’t mark ‘em up so high they never leave the lots, (see GTO, Pontiac, 2004 for more details on this self-defeating strategy) the basement-dwelling hobbits will earn magic sacks of cash in World of Warcraft, enabling them to buy a healthy allocation of GT-Rs year after year, the mandatory annual “tuneup” won’t **** everybody off so badly they dump their Not A Skyline and buy a Z06 after all… it could all happen according to Nissan’s plan. I’m a bit of a Datsun/Nissan fan, you know. My first car was a bad-assed two-tone 200SX fastback. I made the hilariously stupid decision to sell Infinitis when I graduated from school simply because I loved the Q45 and I wanted to have one as a demo. (That wish was never granted, by the way, as it was hard enough to sell those cars without six thousand miles on them.) I still smile when I see a young person in a 350Z. It reaffirms my hope that automotive enthusiasm in this country hasn’t gone the way of the Prius, I mean, the dodo. Nissan makes good cars, and I think the GT-R is going to be a good car. I’m having a hard time swallowing all the hype, but make no mistake: the people who do purchase a GT-R are unlikely to regret their purchase.
In the era of the aforementioned Toyota Pious, it’s also important to recognize the magnitude of the chance Nissan has taken by building this R35 model. The GT-R is a moon shot of sorts, an honest attempt to build the best car possible, consequences be damned. I admire that sort of effort; in fact, the last time I saw a car like this - a car which promised to transcend the boundaries of branding in pursuit of matchless excellence - I put not one, but two examples of that car in my driveway. Great cars, too. They show exactly what can be done when a mass-market manufacturer builds a cost-no-object eighty-thousand-dollar vehicle and ignores all the issues of despicable dealers, non-existent brand prestige, and a vanishingly small pool of buyers. You could say that the builder of my cars had a terrifying set of double jumps in front of them, and they pedaled as hard as they could, knowing they might crash but hoping they would soar over the doubters. It was a tremendous effort, and I really, really love the result, my perfect pair of Phaetons…
bonzelite is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 02:09 AM
  #25  
GTR Senior Member
 
bonzelite's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 869
^^^ by the way, I do not wholesale agree with every point he mentions, but he has quite a bit of keen prescience to this subject!
bonzelite is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 04:02 AM
  #26  
GTR Member
 
shahulx's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 59
I grew up playing Gran Turismo.... I play on xbox live :.... I grew up liking Japanese sports cars.... But the article is right and I'm Not the norm.... I'm the only person of all my friends that can afford this car...

I think it will sell fine the 1st year or 2.... It has great press...

People love (media) to show how a car for half the price can beat a big "name" but eventually that will change

Look at the main competitor , the 997 turbo... When it cme out they were saying it was the best bang for the buck, now the media has universally " jumped ship" and say the GTR and maybe R8 is a better car.... But they will continue to sell because of the name

Can the gtr do that? Most people that can afford the car will buy a Porsche , mercedes , bmw or audi or lexus ..... Not a nissan

I hope the article is wrong.... You do have evo and wrx owners that have aged also and see this as the next step vs a us or euro car
shahulx is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 05:48 AM
  #27  
GTR Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
winkie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 240
I think that article is posted up on the forum here somewhere...I agree some good points, but only time will tell the truth on this one.
winkie is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 07:56 AM
  #28  
GTR Member
 
GTRNate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 84
Originally Posted by shahulx
I grew up playing Gran Turismo.... I play on xbox live :.... I grew up liking Japanese sports cars.... But the article is right and I'm Not the norm.... I'm the only person of all my friends that can afford this car...

I think it will sell fine the 1st year or 2.... It has great press...

People love (media) to show how a car for half the price can beat a big "name" but eventually that will change

Look at the main competitor , the 997 turbo... When it cme out they were saying it was the best bang for the buck, now the media has universally " jumped ship" and say the GTR and maybe R8 is a better car.... But they will continue to sell because of the name

Can the gtr do that? Most people that can afford the car will buy a Porsche , mercedes , bmw or audi or lexus ..... Not a nissan

I hope the article is wrong.... You do have evo and wrx owners that have aged also and see this as the next step vs a us or euro car
Great points and it seems we have a lot in common.

-Nate
GTRNate is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 11:09 AM
  #29  
GTR Senior Member
 
rmatt8748's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 517
I read this article a while ago, he makes a good point, and he knows a lot about cars and manufacture moves that might seem similar. I still think that the GTR will be a success. there is a segment for super performance at reasonable cost. The STI and the EVO were a success i think, people spend thousands tuning them, true the GTR is priced at more than 2x the cost of a new STI or EVO, but some of these people have matured. I'm also sure that Nissan knows that it doesn't want to take away from the sales of the 350z, or g37 coupe, i think that they're aimed at a different buyer, and that yeah, while some people always want to have the most powerful and the top of the line and the best....


People still buy Porsche Carrera's which are way below the 911 turbo, and people buy the regular Vette, which is below the zo6, and the new zr1. I think that nissan/infinity has established the 350z and the g35/g37 well enough to have claimed a pretty concrete segment of the market.

Are they perfect? No, but they're priced well below the new m3, and they're solid built cars, they go mighty quick and they turn heads.



With a car like the GTR, it will continue to enjoy a cult following, it's kinda like owning an EVO in a place that's not flooded with them.

When i had my EVO, i got so many looks and thumbs up, people buy cars like this for the performance and for the recognition that comes with it, sure it's not a ferrari, but people don't assume a-hole when they see you in one. It's a lot of psychology. Some people want the symbol, others don't.
rmatt8748 is offline  
Old 03-10-2008, 11:16 AM
  #30  
GTR Senior Member
 
bonzelite's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 869
My biggest concern, and I've maintained before I ever read that article, is simply the GT-R is a very niche-market car. It's not widely known here, and it is priced in a no-mans-land price bracket even at list, having no brand/badge exclusivity to speak of.

I'm convinced it will sell out initially. I'm not totally convinced it will endure the length of it's generation cycle here in the USA. People in this country seem to have ADD when something new and flashy emerges in the automotive world.

The public is fickle and often contradictory. They will say "man, we need something new and innovative.... all of the cars are so typical and bland..." and then when this new thing arrives... is ignored and eventually discontinued, with people actually preferring ultimately the bland and the expected.

I'll be driving the GT-R regardless as I'm the exception to the rule, the freak, and the non-conformist.
bonzelite is offline  


Quick Reply: Will the GTR go the way of the NSX, RX8, others?



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:58 AM.